How to Diet: Does Soy Impact Masculinity?

The rap: “Soy protein powder strips your masculinity!”
—thehealthyhomeeconomist.com

[text_ad]

The real story: “Some people assume that the plant estrogens in soy must be interfering with reproductive hormones in men,” says Christopher D’Adamo, an assistant professor at the University of Maryland School of Medicine in Baltimore. But the evidence to support that claim is scarce.

Testosterone. Fourteen trials have looked at men with a wide range of testosterone levels who consumed different amounts of soy protein or a placebo (typically a dairy food) every day for 25 days to four years.

“In all 14 studies, testosterone levels did not differ between the two groups,” says Jill Hamilton-Reeves, of the University of Kansas, who led a review of them.

Estrogen. Thenewcenturyman.com, a website that helps men “reclaim their masculinity,” gets right to the point: “Soy is creating man boobs.”

The scare may have started with a 2008 report in a medical journal about a 60-year-old Texas man who complained of sore, enlarged breasts and a decreased libido.

Tests revealed that his level of blood estrogens was up to eight times higher than the top of the normal range. The man said he was lactose intolerant and drank three quarts of soymilk a day. That would have given him a daily dose of 360 mg of isoflavones, about 10 times what the average man in Asia consumes.

After the man stopped drinking soymilk, his estrogens returned to normal and his breast tenderness disappeared. No other similar cases have ever been reported.

That’s not surprising. In nine studies, estrogen levels remained within the normal range whether men consumed soy foods, isoflavone supplements, or a placebo.

In the largest trial, Australian researchers told 42 healthy men aged 35 to 62 to eat a diet with either 5 oz. of lean meat or 10 oz. of tofu every day. After a month, there was no difference in blood levels of estradiol (the major estrogen) or testosterone.

Fertility.Tofu a day, sperm goes away,” read the headline in Canada’s The Globe and Mail. The newspaper was describing the results of a 2008 study by researchers at the Harvard School of Public Health.

But the men in the study didn’t eat tofu every day…and their sperm didn’t go away.

Among 99 male patients at a Boston fertility clinic, total sperm count and sperm quality (that is, how well the sperm moved and were shaped) were the same in those who reported consuming the most soy foods (three to four servings a week) as in those who said they never ate soy.

However, the men who ate the most soy had lower sperm concentration, though it was still in the normal range.

Only two good studies have measured what happens when men are fed soy. In the more recent one, researchers gave 32 Canadian young men soy protein with high levels (62 mg) or low levels (2 mg) of isoflavones or milk protein every day for two months.

“Soy protein and isoflavones had no effect on their sperm concentration, sperm count, sperm quality, or semen volume, compared with milk protein,” says co-author Hamilton-Reeves. She concedes, however, that if soy altered the formation of new sperm, two months may have been too short a time to see it.

The earlier study found essentially the same results.

Sources: Fertil. Steril. 94: 997, 2010; Endocr. Pract. 14: 415, 2008; Fertil. Steril. 93: 2095, 2010; Br. J. Nutr. 84: T557, 2000; Hum. Reprod. 23: 2584, 2008; Fertil. Steril. 94: 1717, 2010.

Other relevant links:

• Can eating soy help with certain health problems? See: How to Diet: What are the Benefits of Soy?

• Should you avoid soy to protect your thyroid? See: How to Diet: Does Soy Affect Thyroid Function?

• What affect does soy have on our brains? See: How to Diet: Does Soy Put You at Risk for Cognitive Decline?

5 Replies to “How to Diet: Does Soy Impact Masculinity?”

  1. I am starting to think you can’t believe anything the media reports on diet or medicine. It seems the reporters don’t even read the scientific reports they cover, much less understand anything.

    There was a great article, I think it was in NA Newsletter that showed the various flaws in scientific methodologies commonly used in testing – and why it was dangerous to jump to conclusions based on limited results. I need to find the reference to that, it’s worth rereading. Combined with the human proclivity to jump to conclusions on limited info and confusing correlation with cause, it’s no wonder we are bombarded with conflicting “advice” every day.

    1. From Nutrition Action Healthletter: Our most recent article on the subject, What’s the Catch?, appeared in the April 2014 issue.

  2. I do not see any documentation of studies done on male babies or children and the effects of soy consumption. For example, it would be interesting to know the long term effects of male babies fed exclusively soy milk.

  3. If soy impacted male masculinity, how come there are 4.3 billion Asians? Asia makes up 60% of the world’s current human population despite China’s harsh birth control policies. Asia’s growth rate is about the highest for the modern era and has quadrupled during the last 100 years. Does that not say something about masculinity for male soy consumers?

    1. Actually, although Asians consume more soy than a typical N.A, they don’t consume much, less than 1oz of soy protein a day which is far below what the above studies used. Japanese consume only 8.7g/day, and Chinese 3.4g/day. Warning, myth alert: It’s understandable to assume Asians eat large amounts of soy since they invented the product, however original studies overestimated their consumption, as borne out by the above facts. If you visit Japan or other Asian countries, you will see that they mainly use soy as a condiment, they don’t eat stacks of soy burgers the way a N.A. vegan might. Consider also that Asians who move to N.A. are typically much taller than their ancestors, due to the higher protein diet (and coincidentally lower soy). They also tend to have more N.A. diseases.

      An additional consideration is that Asian soy was originally made as a fermented whole food product, whereas as modern N.A. soy is made via chemical extraction and other processes that produce concentrated soy isoflavones and soy flour used for making soy burgers and other mock products.
      The health benefits and risks of whole food soy and concentrated forms is a complex issue. According to some studies, the methodologies used to create the modern soy product can impact the amount of isoflavones by an order of magnitude. As with most foods/supplements, some is good, too much can be problematic as experienced by the Texan in the above article. It might be wise to stick to whole foods rather than concentrates. You can read more about it here:
      http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1480510/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *